Bismuth Autometallography: Protocol, Specificity, and DifferentiationGorm Danschera, Meredin Stoltenberga, Kåre Kempb, and Roger Pamphlettca Department of Neurobiology, Institute of Anatomy, University of Aarhus, Denmark b National Environmental Research Institute, Roskilde, Denmark c Department of Pathology, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia Correspondence to: Gorm Danscher, Dept. of Neurobiology, Inst. of Anatomy, University of Aarhus, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark. E-mail: gd@neuro.au.dk
We provide a detailed protocol of the autometallographic bismuth technique and evaluate the specificity of the technique. We show by the multi-element technique "proton-induced X-ray microanalysis" (PIXE) that the autometallographic grains contain silver, bismuth, and sulfur, proving that autometallography can be used for specific tracing of bismuth bound as bismuth sulfide clusters in tissue sections from Bi-exposed animals or humans. In sections from animals exposed concurrently to selenium and bismuth, the autometallographic grains also contain selenium. This demonstrates that, if present in excess in the organisms, selenium will bind to exogenous bismuth, creating bismuth selenide clusters. As a further possible control for specificity and as a tool for differentiating among autometallographically detectable metals in sections containing more than one, we describe how bismuth sulfide clusters can be removed from Epon-embedded tissue sections by potassium cyanide. (J Histochem Cytochem 48:15031510, 2000) Key Words: autometallography, heavy metals, sulfide, selenide, histochemistry, bismuth, toxicology
The necessary observations for performing autometallography (AMG) were accomplished in the 19th century by an unknown photographer. He found that an exposed photographic plate, from which the silver bromide crystals had been removed, could not be developed by a normal chemical developer. However, if he added silver nitrate to the developer the picture emerged. Such a silver ion-enriched chemical developer was called a "physical developer" because it was believed that the developing process differed from that of the chemical developer. For no reason whatever, it seems, it was assumed that if the silver ions were added to the developer they were reduced to silver atoms near the catalyst before moving "physically" to the surface of the catalyst, as opposed to the "normal" chemical development in which the silver ions (released from silver bromide crystals in the film) were believed to adhere to the catalyst first and then to be reduced in situ to metallic silver atoms.
That sections from bismuth-treated mice contained catalytic specks that could be traced with AMG was shown by
Bismuth was established as a separate element by Claud J. Geoffroy in 1753. Whereas its soluble compounds are poisonous, its insoluble compounds have been used for centuries as a remedy for several intestinal ailments and disorders, e.g., for treatment of syphilis, as a diuretic, and as an anti-hypertensive drug. Even today such pharmaceutics are used in developed and in third world countries. Relatively recent applications are the use of a combination of antibiotics and bismuth-containing drugs (
Apart from its use in medicine, bismuth is an important element in atomic plants (
Twenty mice of the BALB/c strain and 25 Wistar rats (Møllegaards Breeding Center; Ejby, Denmark) were used. The animals were housed in plastic cages under the following conditions: 12-hr light/dark cycle, 22C, and 50% humidity. They were fed Altromin No 1314 from Brogaarden (Gentofte, Denmark) ad libitum and had free access to tapwater. The study was undertaken in accordance with the Danish and University of Aarhus guidelines for animal welfare. Before perfusion the animals were anesthetized with sodium pentobarbital (50 mg /kg bw) and sacrificed by transcardial perfusion with 3% glutaraldehyde in a 0.1 M phosphate buffer or with 1% paraformaldehyde and 2% glutaraldehyde in a 0.1 M phosphate buffer.
The protocol given below represents an optimized AMG bismuth technique. Autopsy or biopsy specimens from animals that have been exposed to bismuth, e.g., by using bismuth-containing drugs or having bismuth shotgun pellets implanted, can either be frozen and cut on a cryostat or fixed in buffered formaldehyde- or glutaraldehyde-containing fixatives. Some animals were exposed concurrently to selenium and bismuth. Optimally fixed tissue blocks can be obtained by transcardial perfusion with glutaraldehyde and/or formaldehyde in a 0.1 M phosphate buffer for approximately 10 min, followed by immersion in the fixative for at least 2 hr. Seemingly, the fixatives have no damaging effects on bismuthsulfideselenide clusters. Tissue can be stored in the fixatives for at least 1 year, and most likely for many more years, as is the case with tissue that holds mercurysulfideselenide clusters ( The fixed tissue blocks can either be frozen and cut on a cryostat or embedded in paraffin, methacrylate, or Epon. For ultrastructural studies it is advisable to cut 100-µm sections on a vibratome (see below). The cryostat, paraffin-, or Epon-embedded sections are placed on Farmer-rinsed glass slides. In cases where the sections are cut from fixed tissue blocks, the glass slides should always be dipped in a 0.5% gelatin solution and allowed to dry before use. After being placed on the glass slides and allowed to settle, all sections should be covered with a thin film of gelatin by being dipped in the above gelatin solution. The sections are now ready for AMG development.
The Silver Lactate AMG Developer (
Finally, mix Solution I (60 ml), Solution II or III (10 ml), and Solution IV (15 ml) carefully in a 100-ml Farmer-cleaned beaker. Add Solution V immediately before use.
AMG Silver Enhancement of Tissue Sections
The development can, of course, also take place on the glass slides by covering the sections with the developer, or the sections can be developed floating in the developer. In that case, the dish temperature should likewise be kept at 26C. In cases where short development periods are optimal, one can observe the sections in the microscope while developing (
Semithin sections are placed on a glass slide and AMG developed. After thorough rinsing of the section surface, place a drop of unpolymerized resin on the semithin section to be studied in the electron microscope and place a blank resin block on top. After 24 hr at 60C, remove the block from the glass slide by placing the preparation on a 90C hotplate for about 30 sec. After trimming, cut ultrathin sections and place on a grid. Ultrathin sections treated according to the procedures given above can be stained conventionally with lead citrate and uranyl acetate.
EM Vibratome Technique
Post-AMG Procedures
Additional Cleaning of Section Surface
Controls of Specificity
PIXE Analysis
The above-delineated technique results in a detailed pattern of bismuth-specific AMG grains that can be observed at LM and EM levels in sections from different organs of bismuth-exposed experimental animals, e.g., brain, spinal cord, and kidney (Fig 2 Fig 3 Fig 4 Fig 5 Fig 6 Fig 7). Comparable sections from animals that were not exposed to bismuth were blank (Fig 8), as were bismuth-containing sections that had been treated with potassium cyanide (Fig 9).
PIXE analysis of AMG-developed sections from kidneys of bismuth-exposed rats revealed the presence of silver, bismuth, and sulfur atoms, while sections from animals that had been treated simultaneously with selenium contained selenium as well. Isolated AMG grains from the two sources contained Ag, Bi, S and Ag, Bi, S, Se, respectively. The yields in the PIXE spectra for Bi and Se relative to Ag were, however, much lower in spectra from the separated grains than from the developed sections (Fig 10). The reason is probably that a size fractionation of the AMG grains takes place during the centrifugation. It is mainly the coarse grains (around 0.5 µm) that are isolated. These grains have a relatively high Ag content (cf. Fig 1). Further Bi and Se are embedded in the center of the grains, which leads to attenuation of the X-ray signals from Bi and Se. The PIXE data are in accordance with these hypotheses. No conclusions can be drawn with respect to sulfur because the sulfur content associated with Bi in all cases is much lower than sulfur of other origin.
As mentioned in the introduction, AMGsilver enhancement of accumulations of bismuth in mice exposed to bismuth subnitrate was introduced by Ross et al. in 1994. Their controls were blank sections from untreated animals, and they did not try to further evaluate the specificity of the technique or the chemical nature of the catalytic bismuth accumulations. In the present study we describe protocols on techniques available for performance of optimal AMG studies at LM and EM levels, and data suggesting that the catalytic bismuth compounds are bismuthsulfideselenide clusters. Based on the multi-element analysis (PIXE) of sections and AMG grain samples, it can be deduced with a reasonable degree of certainty that the AMG catalysts in question are small clusters, i.e., crystal lattices, of Bi2Se3 and Bi2S3. Because the AMG grain isolation technique results in a fraction of grains approximately 0.5 µm in size, the amounts of Bi, S, and Se relative to silver were low. In contrast, PIXE analysis of AMG-developed tissue sections containing all sizes of AMG grains revealed high relative levels of the three elements. The possibility of the existence of a non-sulfideselenide-bound bismuth pool in the sections cannot be excluded from the present study but will be further analyzed.
Because the AMG technique is a tool for revealing several endogenous and exogenous metals in tissue sections, providing that they are present either as sulfideselenide clusters (Ag, Hg, and Bi) or as pure metal clusters (Au and Ag), it is of some importance to be able to differentiate among the different metals if they are present in the same tissue. Protocols to this end have previously been worked out for Au, Zn, Ag, and Hg (
The only metal sulfideselenide cluster that is known to be resistant to cyanide is mercury (
Despite these chemical possibilities for removing the different kinds of catalytic clusters from Epon sections, it should be stressed that use of a multi-element analysis is crucial for a precise and secure knowledge about the nature of the AMG metals present in a section for which the composition is not known in advance ( To summarize, the above protocols are based on the most recent AMG technology and describe the optimal procedures for LM and EM analysis of tissues containing bismuth sulfide clusters. It is shown that AMG grains in tissue sections from animals that were simultaneously exposed to bismuth and selenium cause creation of bismuth selenide clusters or bismuthsulfideselenide clusters. Ways to control specificity and to differentiate bismuth from other AMG metals in tissue sections are presented. The AMG bismuth technique should be of value to researchers in the field.
Supported by the "Direktør E. Danielsen and Hustrus Fond," the Aarhus University Research Foundation, and the Danish Medical Research Council. We wish to thank Ms H. Brandstrup, Ms D. Jensen, Ms H. Mikkelsen, Ms K. Wiedemann, Mr A. Meier, and Mr T.A. Nielsen for excellent technical assistance. Received for publication February 28, 2000; accepted June 1, 2000.
Brunk U, Brun A, Sköld G (1968) Histochemical demonstration of heavy metals with the sulphide-silver method: a methodological study. Acta Histochem 31:345-357[Medline] Danscher G (1982) Exogenous selenium in the brain. A histochemical technique for light and electron microscopical localization of catalytic selenium bonds. Histochemistry 76:281-293[Medline] Danscher G (1984) Autometallography. A new technique for light and electron microscopic visualization of metals in biological tissue (gold, silver, metal sulphides and metal selenides). Histochemistry 81:331-335[Medline] Danscher G, Jensen KB, Kraft J, Stoltenberg M (1997a) Autometallographic silver enhancement of submicroscopic metal containing catalytic crystallitesa histochemical tool for detection of gold, silver, bismuth, mercury, and zinc. Cell Vis 4:375-386
Danscher G, Juhl S, Stoltenberg M, Krunderup B, Schrøder HD, Andreasen A (1997b) Autometallographic silver enhancement of zinc sulfide crystals created in cryostat sections from human brain biopsies. A new technique that makes it feasible to demonstrate zinc ions in tissue sections from biopsies and early autopsy material. J Histochem Cytochem 45:1503-1510 Danscher G, MøllerMadsen B (1985) Silver amplification of mercury sulfide and selenide. A histochemical method for light and electron microscopic localization of mercury in tissue. J Histochem Cytochem 33:219-228[Abstract] Hacker GW, Grimelius L, Danscher G, Bernatzky G, Muss W, Adam H, Thurner J (1988) Silver acetate autometallography. An alternative enhancement technique for immunogold-silver staining (IGSS) and silver amplification of gold, silver, mercury and zinc in tissues. J Histotechnol 11:213-221 Hainfeld JF, Powell RD, Stein JK, Hacker GW, HauserKronberger C, Cheung ALM, Schöfer C (1999) Gold-based Autometallography. Proc 57th Ann Mtg Microsc Soc Am. New York, Springer-Verlag, pp. 486487
Haug F-M
Haug F-M Hopkins RJ (1997) Current FDA-approved treatments for Helicobacter pylori and the FDA approval process. Gastroenterology 113(suppl 6):S126-130[Medline] Kemp K, Danscher G (1979) Multi-element analysis of the rat hippocampus by proton-induced X-ray emission spectroscopy (phosphorous, sulphur, chlorine, potassium, calcium, iron, zinc, copper, lead, bromine and rubidium). Histochemistry 59:167-176[Medline] Liesegang RE (1911) Die Kolloidchemie der histologischen Silberfärbungen. In Ostwald W, ed. Kolloidchemische Beihefte (Ergänzungshefte zur Kolloid-Zeitschrift). Monographien zur reinen und angewandten Kolloidchemie. Dresden, Leipzig, Verlag von Theodor Steinkopff, 1-44 Lormée P, Lécolle S, Septier D, le Denmat D, Goldberg M (1989) Autometallography for histochemical visualization of rat incisor polyanions with cuprolinic blue. J Histochem Cytochem 37:203-208[Abstract] Pamphlett R, Danscher G, Rungby J, Stoltenberg M (2000) Tissue uptake of bismuth from shotgun pellets. Environ Res 82:258-262[Medline] Roberts WJ (1935) A new procedure for detection of gold in animal tissue. Proc R Acad (Amsterdam) 38:540-544 Ross JF, Broadwell RD, Poston MR, Lawhorn GT (1994) Highest brain bismuth levels and neuropathology are adjacent to fenestrated blood vessels in mouse brain after intraperitoneal dosing of bismuth subnitrate. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 124:191-200[Medline] Ross JF, Switzer RC, Poston MR, Lawhorn GT (1996) Distribution of bismuth in the brain after intraperitoneal dosing of bismuth subnitrate in mice: implications for routes of entry of xenobiotic metals into the brain. Brain Res 725:137-154[Medline]
Sharma RR, Cast IP, Redfern RM, O'Brien C (1994) Extradural application of bismuth iodoform paraffin paste causing relapsing bismuth encephalopathy: case report with CT and MRI studies. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 57:990-993 Stierhof YD, Humble BM, Hermann R, Otten MT, Schwarz H (1992) Direct visualization and silver enhancement of ultra-small antibody-bound gold particles on immunolabeled ultrathin resin sections. Scan Microsc 6:1009-1022 Timm F (1958) Zur Histochemie der Schwermetalle. Das Sulfid-Silber-Verfahren. Dtsch Z Ges Gerichtl Med 46:706-711 Weast RC ((1975) Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||