Splicing Mutations in TP53 in Human Squamous Cell Carcinoma Lines Influence Immunohistochemical DetectionWolfgang Eichelera, Daniel Zipsa, Annegret Dörflera, Reidar Grénmanc, and Michael Baumanna,ba Department of Radiotherapy and Radiation Oncology, Turku University, Turku, Finland b Experimental Center, Turku University, Turku, Finland c Medical Faculty Carl Gustav Carus, Technical University Dresden, Dresden, Germany, and Department of OtorhinolaryngologyHead and Neck Surgery and Department of Medical Biochemistry, Turku University, Turku, Finland Correspondence to: Wolfgang Eicheler, Uniklinikum, Klinik für Strahlentherapie und Radioonkologie, Fetscherstr. 74, 01307 Dresden, Germany. E-mail: wolfgang.eicheler@mailbox.tu-dresden.de
The mutational status of the tumor suppressor gene TP53 is often examined by immunohistochemistry. We compared the incidence of TP53 mutations in 12 permanent squamous cell carcinoma lines of the head and neck with the immunohistochemical staining obtained with two different antibodies. The mutational status of the TP53 gene was assessed by sequencing the complete coding frame of the TP53 mRNA. All 12 tumor cell lines had TP53 mutations. Six of them showed missense mutations and five had premature stop codons caused either by splicing mutations or nonsense mutations or by exon skipping. One tumor cell line was heterozygous, with a truncating splicing mutation and an additional missense mutation located on different alleles. In one case, an in-frame insertion of 23 extra codons was found. All missense mutations were positive in immunhistochemistry and Western blotting. The truncated p53 was not immunohistochemically detected in three cases with the DO-7 antibody and in five cases with the G59-12 antibody, giving false-negative results in 25% or 40%, respectively, of all tumor cell lines examined. We conclude that splicing mutations are common in squamous cell carcinoma lines and that the incidence of p53 inactiviation by erroneous splicing is higher than yet reported. Sequencing of only the exons of TP53 may miss intronic mutations leading to missplicing and may therefore systematically underestimate the TP53 mutation frequency. (J Histochem Cytochem 50:197204, 2002) Key Words: p53, squamous cell carcinoma, mutation, immunohistochemistry, splicing, exon skipping
EXAMINATION of the mutational status of the p53 gene (TP53) by immunohistochemistry (IHC) or sequencing is widely used in cancer research. Immunohistochemical detection is based on the fact that the half-life of the mutated p53 protein is often increased, leading to its accumulation in the nucleus. In contrast, the wild-type protein has a shorter half-life and steady-state levels are not detectable by conventional IHC. When compared systematically, the correlation of IHC staining of p53 protein and the mutational status of TP53 was only weak in some studies (
In human head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (hnSCC), p53 overexpression, as assessed by IHC, varied between 34 and 79% in different studies (
Conflicting reports were also given with regard to the effect of TP53 mutations in the response of hnSCC cell lines to radiation therapy ( In the present study we examined 12 different hnSCC lines, which are currently used in our laboratory for radiobiological experiments. We sequenced the complete reading frame of TP53 using cDNA derived from the mRNA to account for splicing artifacts and alternative splicing and, if necessary, the corresponding intron sequences at the DNA level to identify the underlying intronic mutation. The mutational status was compared to the detection of the p53 protein in IHC on paraffin sections and in Western blotting.
hSCC Cell Lines
FaDu (ATCC HTB-43), an undifferentiated human hypopharygeal SCC cell line (
FaDuDD is a subline of ATCC HTB-43, which has been used in different laboratories for radiobiological experiments in nude mice and in vitro since the 1980s (
SKX was established as a xenograft line in nude mice from a biopsy of a moderately differentiated SCC of the floor of the mouth in 1991. In 1999, a cell line was established in vitro from the xenograft line (
GL is a moderately differentiated keratinizing SCC line, which was established as a permanent xenograft line in nude mice from a surgical specimen of an advanced human laryngeal carcinoma ( The MKG7 xenograft tumor line was derived from a gingival tumor (courtesy of Dr. R. Schimming; Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, University of Dresden, Germany).
The UT-SCC-5, UT-SCC-10, UT-SCC-14, UT-SCC-15, UT-SCC-16a, and UT-SCC-24b tumor cell lines were established from tumors of the mobile tongue. The UT-SCC-33 tumor line came from the gingiva of the maxilla. The tumor lines designated "UT-SCC" were established at the Department of OtorhinolaryngologyHead and Neck Surgery (Turku University; Turku, Finland) as described earlier ( As wild-type controls, human lymphocytes were isolated from the peripheral blood of voluntary donors by centrifugation (1200 x g, 20 min) through a Ficoll 400 cushion (D = 1.077 at 20C; Biochrom, Berlin, Germany).
Immunohistochemistry
Sequencing of TP53
LOH Analysis for TP53 Locus in FaDu and FaDudd
Sequence Data Analysis
Western Blotting
All 12 SCC lines showed mutations in TP53 (Table 1). SKX, GL, FaDu, UT-SCC-5, UT-SCC-16a, UT-SCC-33, and MKG7 had missense mutations resulting in amino acid changes. FaDu had an additional heterozygous splicing site mutation causing a 49-bp insertion of intron 7 sequence with a frameshift and a premature stop codon. The FaDuDD subline showed only the splicing site mutation, indicating the loss of one allele. This loss of heterozygosity (LOH) was confirmed by the analysis of a repeat polymorphism in TP53 (Fig 1). UT-SCC-10 showed two heterozygous nonsense mutations causing premature stops in codon 144 and codon 306. The mutation in codon 306 was not seen in the RNA sequence, indicating that these mutations were located on different alleles, one of them being not transcribed. All other base changes found were classified as homo- or hemizygous according to the absence of double peaks in the electropherograms of the sequencing reaction. UT-SCC-15 showed erroneous splicing with the insertion of 17 bp of intron 10 due to a splicing site mutation. In UT-SCC-24b, a splicing site mutation caused an in-frame insertion of a 69-bp intronic sequence with the creation of additional 23 codons after codon 224. UT-SCC-14 exhibited a complete skipping of exon 8 in the mRNA. However, we could not identify any underlying genomic mutation. The flanking sequences from intron 7 to 9 as well as the affected exon 8 were wild-type in three individually sequenced specimens (Table 1). The sequence of intron 7 in UT-SCC-14 differed significantly from the published GenBank sequence (Genbank entries
U94788 and
X54156) but was identical to the sequence found in the control lymphocytes and the published sequence of the A549 (ATCC CCL-185) human lung carcinoma cell line and the human malignant glioma-derived cell line M059J (
Owing to the aberrant size, the mRNA in FaDuDD, UT-SCC-14, and UT-SCC-24b was classified as mutant after agarose gel electrophoresis (Fig 2), but the 17-bp insertion in UT-SCC-15 was detected only in high-resolution polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (not shown).
The IHC staining did not reflect well the mutation status. Nine of 12 tumor cell lines showed nuclear staining with the DO-7 antibody, and three tumor cell lines with premature stops at codons 144, 202, and 244, respectively, were negative (Fig 3). UT-SCC-14, which had a premature stop at codon 290, showed immunoreaction with the DO-7 antibody. The G59-12 antibody, which detects an epitope at the C-terminus of p53, positively stained only seven of the tumor cell lines. No immunoreaction with G59-12 was seen in all tumor lines with premature stop codons, regardless of the size of the truncated protein. In addition, the UT-SCC-24b, which showed 23 additional codons between codon 224 and codon 225, was negative with G59-12. As seen with DO-7, all tumor cell lines harboring a missense mutation (including FaDu with the additional heterozygous splicing mutation) showed nuclear accumulation of p53 with the G59-12 antibody.
Both the full-length and the truncated p53 were detected in Western blotting in six tumor cell lines, with the exeption of the truncated protein in FaDuDD, UT-SCC-10, UT-SCC-15, and the extended protein in UT-SCC-24b, which were negative (Fig 4).
The IHC staining did not reflect the mutational status of human SCC lines in this study. Despite the fact that only a limited set of tumor models was examined, some correlations between IHC staining and mutation type were obvious. Truncated p53 protein, as it appears after erroneous splicing, appears to have a shorter half-life and escapes IHC detection. In the hnSCC lines described here, we found missplicing in 5/12 tumor lines due to intronic point mutations or to a still unknown mechanism in one case. These alterations resulted in frameshifts and eventually premature stop codons, and gave rise to a high incidence (2540%) of false-negative p53 immunostaining. FaDu was heterozygous for a splicing mutation and on the other allele an additional missense mutation in codon 248. Therefore, the nuclear immunostaining and the 53-kD band in Western blots were derived from the correctly spliced allele, whereas the other allele was transcribed only at very low levels (
In UT-SCC-14, we found incorrect splicing even with correct splicing sites and an intact putative branch point 40 bp upstream of the 3' splicing site of intron 7, compared to the corresponding sequence in normal human lymphocytes and the published sequences for the cell lines A549 (ATCC CCL-185) and M059J. The exact homologies between our human lymphocytes, UT-SCC-14, M059J, and A549 suggest that they represent the wild-type sequence for intron 7 rather than the sequences in the GenBank entries
U94788 and
X54156 (
Most of the truncating mutations described in head and neck SCC thus far were attributed to intra-exon insertions rather than to erroneous splicing (
Sequencing of TP53 either by manual, automated, or a new gene chip assay was shown to yield substantial false-negative rates in primary lung cancer tissue due to the mixture of mutant and wild-type cells in that material ( In conclusion, the high incidence of TP53 mutations recently reported for clinical tumors is in agreement with our findings in a set of 12 hnSCC lines and supports the value of these model systems for oncological research. The potential pitfall of false-negative results in IHC due to a high incidence of truncating mutations in TP53 suggests that more attention needs to be focused on this type of p53 inactivation, presumably by sequencing the RNA messenger rather than the exons at the DNA level.
Supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Grant Ba 1433/2). We thank Ms M. Oelsner and Ms S. Balschukat for skillful technical assistance and Dipl Ing V. Lieder (Computing Center of the Medical Faculty Carl Gustav Carus, Technical University Dresden) for help with the artwork. Received for publication March 27, 2001; accepted September 12, 2001.
Ahomadegbe JC, Barrois M, Fogel S, Le Bihan ML, DoucRasy S, Duvillard P, Armand JP, Riou G (1995) High incidence of p53 alterations (mutation, deletion, overexpression) in head and neck primary tumors and metastases; absence of correlation with clinical outcome. Frequent protein overexpression in normal epithelium and in early non-invasive lesions. Oncogene 10:1217-1227[Medline]
Ahrendt SA, Halachmi S, Chow JT, Wu L, Halachmi N, Yang SC, Wehage S, Jen J, Sidransky D (1999) Rapid p53 sequence analysis in primary lung cancer using an oligonucleotide probe array. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96:7382-7387 Anderson CW, AllalunisTurner MJ (2000) Human p53 from the malignant glioma-derived cell lines M059J and M059K has a cancer-associated mutation in exon 8. Radiat Res 154:473-476[Medline] Baumann M (1994) Fraktionierte Strahlentherapie menschlicher FaDu-Plattenepithelkarzinome in Nacktmäusen. Habilitationsschrift, Universität Hamburg Baumann M, Pu A, duBois W, Suit HD (1992) Quantitative evaluation of the effects of cotransplantation of heavily irradiated human tumor cells and of different immunsuppressive measures of the xenotransplantability of a human squamous cell carcinoma into athymic nude mice. Contrib Oncol 42:98-107 Bosari S, Viale G (1995) The clinical significance of p53 aberrations in human tumours. Virchows Arch 427:229-241[Medline]
Brachman DG, Beckett M, Graves D, Haraf D, Vokes E, Weichselbaum RR (1993) p53 mutation does not correlate with radiosensitivity in 24 head and neck cancer cell lines. Cancer Res 53:3667-3669 Calzolari A, Chiarelli I, Bianchi S, Messerini L, Gallo O, Porfirio B, Mattiuz PL (1997) IHC vs molecular biology methods. Complementary techniques for effective screening of p53 alterations in head and neck cancer. Am J Clin Pathol 107:7-11[Medline] Dörfler A, Eicheler W, Zips D, Petersen C, Baumann M (2000) Etablierung uns Charakterisierung der strahlenempfindlichen Plattenepithelkarzinom-Zellinie SKX in vitro. Exp Strahlenther Klin Strahlenbiol 9:11-13 Eicheler W, Baumann M (2001) Wildtype sequence of TP53, intron 7. Radiat Res 155:641[Medline] Flamman J-M, Waridel F, Estreicher A, Vannier A, Limacher J-M, Gilbert D, Iggo R, Frebourg T (1996) The human tumour suppressor gene p53 is alternatively spliced in normal cells. Oncogene 12:813-818[Medline] Fracchiolla NS, Pignataro L, Capaccio P, Trecca D, Boletini A, Ottaviani A, Polli E, Maiolo AT, Neri A (1995) Multiple genetic lesions in laryngeal squamous cell carcinomas. Cancer 75:1292-1301[Medline] Fukuda I, Ogawa K (1992) Alternatively-spliced p53 mRNA in the FAA-HTC1 rat hepatoma cell line without the splice site mutations. Cell Struct Funct 17:427-432[Medline] Ganly I, Soutar DS, Brown R, Kaye SB (2000) p53 alterations in recurrent squamous cell cancer of the head and neck refractory to radiotherapy. Br J Cancer 82:392-398[Medline]
Greenblatt MS, Bennett WP, Hollstein M, Harris CC (1994) Mutations in the p53 tumor suppressor gene: clues to cancer etiology and molecular pathogenesis. Cancer Res 54:4855-4878 Grénman R, PekkolaHeino K, Joensuu H, Aitasalo K, Klemi P, Lakkala T (1992) UT-MUC-1, a new mucoepidermoid carcinoma cell line and its radiation sensitivity. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 118:542-547
Han KA, KuleszMartin MF (1992) Alternatively splicing p53 RNA in transformed and normal cells of different tissue types. Nucleic Acids Res 20:1979-1981 Harris CC (1996) The 1995 Walter Hubert Lecturemolecular epidemiology of human cancer: insights from the mutational analysis of the p53 tumour-suppressor gene. Br J Cancer 73:261-269[Medline] Kropveld A, Rozemuller EH, Leppers FG, Scheidel KC, de Weger RA, Koole R, Hordijk GJ, Slootweg PJ, Tilanus MG (1999) Sequencing analysis of RNA and DNA of exons 1 through 11 shows p53 gene alterations to be present in almost 100% of head and neck squamous cell cancers. Lab Invest 79:347-353[Medline] Lansford CD, Grénman R, Bier H, Somers KD, Kim S-Y, Whiteside TL, Clayman GL, Welkoborsky H-J, Carey TE (1999) Head and neck cancers. In Masters J, Palsson B, eds. Human Cell Culture. Vol 2. Cancer Cell Lines. Part 2. Dordrecht, Kluwer Academic Press, 185-255 Lazar V, Hazard F, Bertin F, Janin N, Bellet D, Bressac B (1993) Simple sequence repeat polymorphism within the p53 gene. Oncogene 8:1703-1705[Medline]
Lorson CL, Hahnen E, Androphy EJ, Wirth B (1999) A single nucleotide in the SMN gene regulates splicing and is responsible for spinal muscular atrophy. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96:6307-6311 Nakai H, Kaneko H, Horiike S, Ariyama Y, Misawa S, Kashima K, Ishizaki K (1994) Multiple aberrant splicing of the p53 transcript without genomic mutations around exon-intron junctions in a case of chronic myelogenous leukaemia in blast crisis: a possible novel mechanism of p53 inactivation. Br J Haematol 8:839-842 Nieder C, Petersen S, Petersen C, Thames HD (2000) The challenge of p53 as prognostic and predictive factor in gliomas. Cancer Treat Rev 26:67-73[Medline] Nylander K, Dabelsteen E, Hall PA (2000) The p53 molecule and its prognostic role in squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck. J Oral Pathol Med 29:413-425[Medline] Nylander K, Nilsson P, Mehle C, Roos G (1995) p53 mutations, protein expression and cell proliferation in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck. Br J Cancer 71:826-830[Medline] Petersen C, Baumann M, Dubben H-H, Arps H, Melenkeit A, Helfrich J (1998) Linear-quadratic analysis of tumour response to fractionated radiotherapy: a study on human squamous cell carcinoma xenografts. Int J Radiat Biol 73:197-205[Medline] Petersen S, Thames Nieder C, Petersen C, Baumann M (2001) The results of colorectal cancer treatment by p53 status: a treatment-specific overview. Dis Colon Rectum 44:322-333[Medline] Pulkkinen JO, Servomaa K, Pekkola K, Kulmala J, Grenman R (2000) The effect of irradiation on mitotic and apoptotic frequency in head and neck cancer cell lines, the correlation to p53 mutations and clonogenic survival. Anticancer Res 20:1503-1512[Medline] Rangan SR (1972) A new human cell line (FaDu) from a hypopharyngeal carcinoma. Cancer 29:117-121[Medline] RaybaudDiogene H, Tetu B, Morency R, Fortin A, Monteil RA (1996) p53 overexpression in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: review of the literature. Eur J Cancer Oral Oncol 32B:143-149 Reiss M, Brash DE, MunozAntonia T, Simon JA, Ziegler A, Vellucci VF, Zhou ZL (1993) Status of the p53 tumor suppressor gene in human squamous carcinoma cell lines. Oncol Res 1992;4:349-357 Saunders ME, MacKenzie R, Shipman R, Fransen E, Gilbert R, Jordan RC (1999) Patterns of p53 gene mutations in head and neck cancer: full-length gene sequencing and results of primary radiotherapy. Clin Cancer Res 1999 5:2455-2463 Sauter ER, Ridge JA, Litwin S, Langer CJ (1995) Pretreatment p53 protein expression correlates with decreased survival in patients with endstage head and neck cancer. Clin Cancer Res 1:1407-1412[Abstract] Servomaa K, Kiuru A, Grenman R, PekkolaHeino K, Pulkkinen JO, Rytömaa T (1996) p53 mutations associated with increased sensitivity to ionizing radiation in human head and neck cancer cell lines. Cell Prolif 29:219-230[Medline]
Suit HD, Sedlacek RS, Zietman A (1988) Quantitative transplantation assays of spontaneous tumors of the C3H mouse as allografts in athymic NCr/Sed-nu/nu nude mice and isografts in C3Hf/Sed mice. Cancer Res 48:4525-4528 Suit HD, Sedlacek RS, Zietman A (1990) Radiation response of xenografts of a human squamous cell carcinoma and a glioblastoma multiforme: a progress report. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 18:365-373[Medline]
van Houten VMM, Tabor MP, van den Brekel MWM, Denkers F, Wishaupt RGA, Kummer JA, Snow GB, Brakenhoff RH (2000) Molecular assays for the diagnosis of minimal residual head-and-neck cancer: Methods, reliability, pitfalls, and solutions. Clin Cancer Res 6:3803-3816
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||