Volume 53 (5): 621-629, 2005 Copyright ©The Histochemical Society, Inc. BRCA1 Gene Expression in Breast Cancer : A Correlative Study between Real-time RT-PCR and Immunohistochemistry
Department of Pathology, Faculty of Medicine, Kuwait University, Kuwait Correspondence to: Dr. Fahd Al-Mulla, Department of Pathology, Molecular Pathology Laboratory, Faculty of Medicine, Kuwait University, PO Box 24923, Safat 13110, Kuwait. E-mail: fahd{at}al-mulla.org
Breast cancer is a major cause of cancer-related mortality in women. There are major discrepancies concerning the usefulness of various antibodies in detecting breast cancer susceptibility gene 1 (BRCA1) protein and its subcellular localization. The aim of the present study was to determine the specificity and sensitivity of immunohistochemistry (IHC) as a screening method for demonstrating BRCA1 expression. BRCA1 gene expression in archival paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissues was studied simultaneously at the protein and mRNA levels, and the two findings were compared. Forty-eight archival paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissues were studied for BRCA1 gene expression at protein level by IHC using four different antibodies against different BRCA1 epitopes and at mRNA level using real-time RT-PCR. BRCA1 mRNA expression was reduced or absent in 79% of the samples, and this finding correlated significantly with loss of BRCA1 protein expression in 83% of breast cancer tissues using one BRCA1 antibody studied (AB-1, against N-terminus epitope). The specificity of this antibody was 91.3%, and its sensitivity was 66.6%. There was no significant correlation between BRCA1 mRNA and protein expression as demonstrated by the remaining three antibodies. Antibody 8F7 had the highest sensitivity of 100%, but its specificity was 30.4% if mRNA levels were considered as the reference standard. (J Histochem Cytochem 53:621629, 2005)
Key Words: BRCA1 breast cancer immunohistochemistry mRNA protein real-time RT-PCR
BREAST CANCER is a major cause of cancer-related mortality in women (Hill et al. 1997
There are major discrepancies concerning the usefulness of various antibodies in detecting BRCA1 protein expression and localization. Different studies have generated conflicting results related to BRCA1 expression and the subcellular localization of this protein. This controversy is even more pronounced when paraffin-embedded tissues are used (Wilson et al. 1999
BRCA1 has been claimed to be exclusively a nuclear protein in both normal and cancer cells (Scully et al. 1996 This study focused on BRCA1 expression status in paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissues by using RT-PCR and IHC and correlated the results of the two. Such a comparison could be useful in assessing the specificity of commercially available BRCA1 antibodies.
Forty-eight archival formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissues of female patients (aged 2965 years) were randomly chosen and used for the study. The genetic background of the population studied was unknown. Sections of 5-µm thickness were cut from each tissue. One section was stained with hematoxylin and eosin to confirm the diagnosis, type, and grading of the tumor. The remaining sections were stored for use in IHC and RNA extraction. Histological grading of the carcinomas was done according to the system of Scarff-Bloom-Richardson (Dalton et al. 1994
Immunohistochemistry
Subcellular localization of staining was categorized as cytoplasmic, nuclear, or both cytoplasmic and nuclear.
RNA Extraction and Real-time RT-PCR
Statistical Analysis
Breast cancers were categorized according to their histological type. Five main histological types were present in this study: infiltrative ductal carcinoma (35 cases), intraductal carcinoma (1 case), medullary carcinoma (7 cases), infiltrative lobular carcinoma (3 cases), and tubulo-lobular carcinoma (2 cases). The most common histological type was infiltrative ductal carcinoma, which accounted for 72.8% of cases. In this study, cancers with total score of 3 to 5 were considered low grade; and those with scores of 6 to 9 were considered high grade. Of the 48 breast cancer cases, 37 (77%) were of high histological grade (Table 2).
Immunohistochemistry Table 3 summarizes the BRCA1 protein expression and its subcellular localization in 48 breast cancer tissues using the four different antibodies.
Monoclonal Antibody against N-terminus, AB-1 IHC using monoclonal antibody against N-terminus, AB-1 showed positive staining for BRCA1 protein in only 16.7% of cases. In 87.5% of these cases, staining was localized in the cytoplasm. The remaining 12.5% showed staining in both the cytoplasm and nuclei (Figure 1A).
Monoclonal Antibody against Exon-11, AB-8F7 Monoclonal antibody against exon-11, AB-8F7 showed positive BRCA1 protein staining in 64.6% of cases. In half of these cases, staining was nuclear and cytoplasmic. In the remaining half, staining was cytoplasmic only (Figure 1B).
Polyclonal Antibody against N-terminus, AB-D20
Polyclonal Antibody against C-terminus, AB-C-terminus Cytoplasmic staining appeared to be the most common pattern, with or without nuclear staining, and none of the antibodies demonstrated nuclear staining only (Tables 2 and 3).
Real-time RT-PCR
Correlation between BRCA1 mRNA and Protein Expression Table 4 compares BRCA1 mRNA expression with corresponding protein expression. BRCA1 mRNA expression in breast cancer tissues showed a significant relationship with protein expression by only one of the antibodies, AB-1 (p=0.002). Thus, 72% of breast cancers, which also did not demonstrate BRCA1 at mRNA level, did not show BRCA1 protein expression by IHC using AB-1. No significant relationship could be detected between BRCA1 mRNA and BRCA1 protein expression using the remaining three antibodies (AB-8F7, AB-D20, and AB-C-terminus).
Specificity and Sensitivity of the Four Different BRCA1 Antibodies To evaluate the specificity and sensitivity of the four anti-BRCA1 antibodies, the RT-PCR results were considered as standard. AB-1 has the best combined specificity (91.3%) and sensitivity (66.6%) in detecting BRCA1 protein (Table 5). Although AB-8F7 had 100% sensitivity, its specificity was low (30.4%).
The present study shows lack of both BRCA1 mRNA and protein expression in the majority of breast cancers studied. This finding is consistent with other reports, which have shown that BRCA1 mRNA and protein are decreased in mammary tumors compared with matched normal breast tissue (Thompson et al. 1995
One of the major tasks of this study was to choose the appropriate and reliable antibody for BRCA1 protein IHC. There is a major controversy about the usefulness and specificity of different BRCA1 antibodies. This controversy is even more pronounced when paraffin-embedded tissues are used. In the present study, four anti-BRCA1 antibodies against different BRCA1 epitopes were used. The results obtained were compared to determine which antibody is most reliable for detecting BRCA1 protein on paraffin-embedded breast cancers. To evaluate the specificity and sensitivity of the four anti-BRCA1 antibodies, the RT-PCR results were considered as a standard. Our results demonstrate a significant relationship between BRCA1 mRNA and BRCA1 protein expression with only one of the antibodies, monoclonal AB-1. Almost all breast cancers that had no or significantly reduced BRCA1 mRNA expression in this study were also negative for BRCA1 protein expression with AB-1 (21/23, 91%; p=0.002). Accordingly, AB-1 has the best combined specificity (91.3%) and sensitivity (66.6%) in detecting BRCA1 protein (Table 5). In a study using four commercially available anti-BRCA1 antibodies on paraffin-embedded breast cancers (including AB-1 and AB-D20 ), Perez-Valles et al. (2001)
The subcellular localization of BRCA1 has been also been controversial. BRCA1 has been claimed to be an exclusively nuclear protein in both normal and cancer cells (Scully et al. 1996
In conclusion, the clinical benefits of establishing BRCA1 expression status and its effects on breast cancer treatment, prophylaxis, and prognosis are obvious (Lafarge et al. 2001
This study was funded by the College of Graduate Studies of Kuwait University and the Kuwait Institute for the Advancement of Sciences, project number 990707 (FA-M), and Shared Facility Grant, number GM/0101. We wish to thank Dr. Josley George, Dr. Shirley George, Mrs. Bency John, and Mrs. Tessy Saji for their technical support.
1 These authors contributed equally to this work. Received for publication October 5, 2004; accepted December 9, 2004
Baldassarre G, Battista S, Belletti B, Thakur S, Pentimalli F, Trapasso F, Fedele M, et al. (2003) Negative regulation of BRCA1 gene expression by HMGA1 proteins accounts for the reduced BRCA1 protein levels in sporadic breast carcinoma. Mol Cell Biol 23:22252238 Bernard-Gallon DJ, Crespin NC, Maurizis JC, Bignon YJ (1997) Cross-reaction between antibodies raised against the last 20 C-terminal amino acids of BRCA 1 (C-20) and human EGF and EGF-R in MCF 10a human mammary epithelial cell line. Int J Cancer 71:123126[CrossRef][Medline] Chen CF, Li S, Chen Y, Chen PL, Sharp ZD, Lee WH (1996) The nuclear localization sequences of the BRCA1 protein interact with the importin-alpha subunit of the nuclear transport signal receptor. J Biol Chem 271:3286332868 Chen Y, Chen CF, Riley DJ, Allred DC, Chen PL, Von Hoff D, Osborne CK, et al. (1995) Aberrant subcellular localization of BRCA1 in breast cancer. Science 270:789791 Coene E, Van Oostveldt P, Willems K, van Emmelo J, De Potter CR (1997) BRCA1 is localized in cytoplasmic tube-like invaginations in the nucleus. Nat Genet 16:122124[CrossRef][Medline] Dalton LW, Page DL, Dupont WD (1994) Histologic grading of breast carcinoma. A reproducibility study. Cancer 73:27652770[CrossRef][Medline] Dobrovic A, Simpfendorfer D (1997) Methylation of the BRCA1 gene in sporadic breast cancer. Cancer Res 57:33473350 Easton DF, Ford D, Bishop DT (1995) Breast and ovarian cancer incidence in BRCA1-mutation carriers. Breast Cancer Linkage Consortium. Am J Hum Genet 56:265271 Egawa C, Miyoshi Y, Taguchi T, Tamaki Y, Noguchi S (2001) Quantitative analysis of BRCA1 and BRCA2 mRNA expression in sporadic breast carcinomas and its relationship with clinicopathological characteristics. Jpn J Cancer Res 92:624630[CrossRef][Medline] Egawa C, Motomura K, Miyoshi Y, Takamura Y, Taguchi T, Tamaki Y, Inaji H, et al. (2003) Increased expression of BRCA1 mRNA predicts favorable response to anthracycline-containing chemotherapy in breast cancers. Breast Cancer Res Treat 78:4550[CrossRef][Medline] Fabbro M, Rodriguez JA, Baer R, Henderson BR (2002) BARD1 induces BRCA1 intranuclear foci formation by increasing RING-dependent BRCA1 nuclear import and inhibiting BRCA1 nuclear export. J Biol Chem 277:2131521324 Futreal PA, Liu Q, Shattuck-Eidens D, Cochran C, Harshman K, Tavtigian S, Bennett LM, et al. (1994) BRCA1 mutations in primary breast and ovarian carcinomas. Science 266:120122. Hartman AR, Ford JM (2002) BRCA1 induces DNA damage recognition factors and enhances nucleotide excision repair. Nat Genet 32:180184[CrossRef][Medline] Hartman AR, Ford JM (2003) BRCA1 and p53: compensatory roles in DNA repair. J Mol Med 81:700707[CrossRef][Medline] Hill AD, Doyle JM, McDermott EW, O'Higgins NJ (1997) Hereditary breast cancer. Br J Surg 84:13341339[CrossRef][Medline] Hsu LC, Doan TP, White RL (2001) Identification of a gamma-tubulin-binding domain in BRCA1. Cancer Res 61:77137718 Jacquemier J, Eisinger F, Birnbaum D, Sobol H (1995) Histoprognostic grade in BRCA1-associated breast cancer. Lancet 345:1503[Medline] Khoo US, Ozcelik H, Cheung AN, Chow LW, Ngan HY, Done SJ, Liang AC, et al. (1999) Somatic mutations in the BRCA1 gene in Chinese sporadic breast and ovarian cancer. Oncogene 18:46434646[CrossRef][Medline] Lafarge S, Sylvain V, Ferrara M, Bignon YJ (2001) Inhibition of BRCA1 leads to increased chemoresistance to microtubule-interfering agents, an effect that involves the JNK pathway. Oncogene 20:65976606[CrossRef][Medline] Lakhani SR, Gusterson BA, Jacquemier J, Sloane JP, Anderson TJ, van de Vijver MJ, Venter D, et al. (2000) The pathology of familial breast cancer: histological features of cancers in families not attributable to mutations in BRCA1 or BRCA2. Clin Cancer Res 6:782789 Lee WY, Jin YT, Chang TW, Lin PW, Su IJ (1999) Immunolocalization of BRCA1 protein in normal breast tissue and sporadic invasive ductal carcinomas: a correlation with other biological parameters. Histopathology 34:106112[CrossRef][Medline] Lu M, Conzen SD, Cole CN, Arrick BA (1996) Characterization of functional messenger RNA splice variants of BRCA1 expressed in nonmalignant and tumor-derived breast cells. Cancer Res 56:45784581 Lynch HT, Lynch J, Conway T, Watson P, Feunteun J, Lenoir G, Narod S, et al. (1994) Hereditary breast cancer and family cancer syndromes. World J Surg 18:2131[CrossRef][Medline] Mancini DN, Rodenhiser DI, Ainsworth PJ, O'Malley FP, Singh SM, Xing W, Archer TK (1998) CpG methylation within the 5' regulatory region of the BRCA1 gene is tumor specific and includes a putative CREB binding site. Oncogene 16:11611169[CrossRef][Medline] Merajver SD, Pham TM, Caduff RF, Chen M, Poy EL, Cooney KA, Weber BL, et al. (1995) Somatic mutations in the BRCA1 gene in sporadic ovarian tumours. Nat Genet 9:439443[CrossRef][Medline] Miki Y, Swensen J, Shattuck-Eidens D, Futreal PA, Harshman K, Tavtigian S, Liu Q, et al. (1994) A strong candidate for the breast and ovarian cancer susceptibility gene BRCA1. Science 266:6671 Miyamoto K, Fukutomi T, Asada K, Wakazono K, Tsuda H, Asahara T, Sugimura T, et al. (2002) Promoter hypermethylation and post-transcriptional mechanisms for reduced BRCA1 immunoreactivity in sporadic human breast cancers. Jpn J Clin Oncol 32:7984 Niwa Y, Oyama T, Nakajima T (2000) BRCA1 expression status in relation to DNA methylation of the BRCA1 promoter region in sporadic breast cancers. Jpn J Cancer Res 91:519526[CrossRef][Medline] Orban TI, Olah E (2001) Expression profiles of BRCA1 splice variants in asynchronous and in G1/S synchronized tumor cell lines. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 280:3238[CrossRef][Medline] Perez-Valles A, Martorell-Cebollada M, Nogueira-Vazquez E, Garcia-Garcia JA, Fuster-Diana E (2001) The usefulness of antibodies to the BRCA1 protein in detecting the mutated BRCA1 gene. An immunohistochemical study. J Clin Pathol 54:476480 Rio PG, Maurizis JC, Peffault de Latour M, Bignon YJ, Bernard-Gallon DJ (1999) Quantification of BRCA1 protein in sporadic breast carcinoma with or without loss of heterozygosity of the BRCA1 gene. Int J Cancer 80:823826[CrossRef][Medline] Ruffner H, Verma IM (1997) BRCA1 is a cell cycle-regulated nuclear phosphoprotein. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94:71387143 Russell PA, Pharoah PD, De Foy K, Ramus SJ, Symmonds I, Wilson A, Scott I, et al. (2000) Frequent loss of BRCA1 mRNA and protein expression in sporadic ovarian cancers. Int J Cancer 87:317321[CrossRef][Medline] Scully R, Chen J, Ochs RL, Keegan K, Hoekstra M, Feunteun J, Livingston DM (1997) Dynamic changes of BRCA1 subnuclear location and phosphorylation state are initiated by DNA damage. Cell 90:425435[CrossRef][Medline] Scully R, Ganesan S, Brown M, De Caprio JA, Cannistra SA, Feunteun J, Schnitt S, et al. (1996) Location of BRCA1 in human breast and ovarian cancer cells. Science 272:123126[Medline] Shen SX, Weaver Z, Xu X, Li C, Weinstein M, Chen L, Guan XY, et al. (1998) A targeted disruption of the murine Brca1 gene causes gamma-irradiation hypersensitivity and genetic instability. Oncogene 17:31153124[CrossRef][Medline] Smith TM, Lee MK, Szabo CI, Jerome N, McEuen M, Taylor M, Hood L, et al. (1996) Complete genomic sequence and analysis of 117 kb of human DNA containing the gene BRCA1. Genome Res 6:10291049 Sobczak K, Krzyzosiak WJ (2002) Structural determinants of BRCA1 translational regulation. J Biol Chem 277:1734917358 Sourvinos G, Spandidos DA (1998) Decreased BRCA1 expression levels may arrest the cell cycle through activation of p53 checkpoint in human sporadic breast tumors. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 245:7580[CrossRef][Medline] Thakur S, Zhang HB, Peng Y, Le H, Carroll B, Ward T, Yao J, et al. (1997) Localization of BRCA1 and a splice variant identifies the nuclear localization signal. Mol Cell Biol 17:444452[Abstract] Thomas JE, Smith M, Rubinfeld B, Gutowski M, Beckmann RP, Polakis P (1996) Subcellular localization and analysis of apparent 180-kDa and 220-kDa proteins of the breast cancer susceptibility gene, BRCA1. J Biol Chem 271:2863028635 Thompson ME, Jensen RA, Obermiller PS, Page DL, Holt JT (1995) Decreased expression of BRCA1 accelerates growth and is often present during sporadic breast cancer progression. Nat Genet 9:444450[CrossRef][Medline] Vaughn JP, Davis PL, Jarboe MD, Huper G, Evans AC, Wiseman RW, Berchuck A, et al. (1996) BRCA1 expression is induced before DNA synthesis in both normal and tumor-derived breast cells. Cell Growth Differ 7:711715[Abstract] Vissac C, Peffault De Latour M, Communal Y, Bignon YJ, Bernard-Gallon DJ (2002) Expression of BRCA1 and BRCA2 in different tumor cell lines with various growth status. Clin Chim Acta 320:101110[CrossRef][Medline] Wang H, Shao N, Ding QM, Cui J, Reddy ES, Rao VN (1997) BRCA1 proteins are transported to the nucleus in the absence of serum and splice variants BRCA1a, BRCA1b are tyrosine phosphoproteins that associate with E2F, cyclins and cyclin dependent kinases. Oncogene 15:143157[CrossRef][Medline] Wilson CA, Payton MN, Elliott GS, Buaas FW, Cajulis EE, Grosshans D, Ramos L, et al. (1997) Differential subcellular localization, expression and biological toxicity of BRCA1 and the splice variant BRCA1-delta11b. Oncogene 14:116[CrossRef][Medline] Wilson CA, Ramos L, Villasenor MR, Anders KH, Press MF, Clarke K, Karlan B, et al. (1999) Localization of human BRCA1 and its loss in high-grade, non-inherited breast carcinomas. Nat Genet 21:236240[CrossRef][Medline] Yoshikawa K, Honda K, Inamoto T, Shinohara H, Yamauchi A, Suga K, Okuyama T, et al. (1999) Reduction of BRCA1 protein expression in Japanese sporadic breast carcinomas and its frequent loss in BRCA1-associated cases. Clin Cancer Res 5:12491261 Zhang HT, Zhang X, Zhao HZ, Kajino Y, Weber BL, Davis JG, Wang Q, et al. (1997) Relationship of p215BRCA1 to tyrosine kinase signaling pathways and the cell cycle in normal and transformed cells. Oncogene 14:28632869[CrossRef][Medline] Zhang J, Willers H, Feng Z, Ghosh JC, Kim S, Weaver DT, Chung JH, et al. (2004) Chk2 phosphorylation of BRCA1 regulates DNA double-strand break repair. Mol Cell Biol 24:708718 Zhou C, Smith JL, Liu J (2003) Role of BRCA1 in cellular resistance to paclitaxel and ionizing radiation in an ovarian cancer cell line carrying a defective BRCA1. Oncogene 22:23962404[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||